Great piece!

One of the unexpected but common side effects I’ve noticed with these containment systems in my own clientele is that I frequently get dogs who become extremely fearful of any sort of “digital beeping.” Timers, microwave ovens, cell phones, doorbells, alarm clocks, etc. since most of these collars issue a “warning tone” before actually shocking the dog.

This creates, really quickly, a conditioned punisher that comes back to haunt the dog/handler team in unexpected ways when encountering “every day” sounds like those mentioned above.

Casey Lomonaco
Rewarding Behaviors Dog Training

These otherwise fabulous homes in the burbs need to not leave their dog outside unsupervised, then, with the dog on a long line. Don’t let them talk themselves into thinking it’s humane to shock their dogs into a phobia of beeps little white flags… If they *really* want the dog off leash, at least install a short, allowable fence and install the Invisible Fence along those same boundaries, just to reinforce it. Don’t shock the dog with something invisible!

I know your choice is – no home for this dog or placing it with an otherwise suitable, loving home with an Invisible Fence. I agree that you’re making the right choice. I just don’t think they are making the right choice to have that kind of fence in the first place, with no visible barrier.

I make this concession because, in the Metro New York ‘burbs, many otherwise fabulous homes are absolutely unwilling (and, in many cases, unable, by law or covenant) to use conventional fencing; and they feel that one of the reasons they actually acquired the spacious property they did, was for the enjoyment of the family, with a family dog or dogs. They are well aware that even when supervised, the risk of vehicles in the absence of fencing, is far too great. So, when a great family comes along, who is sincere in their desire to safely keep their dog safe, happens to be perfect for a given dog, and is willing to go the extra mile to work with a reputable company; I am willing to risk and monitor the dog’s placement with them, rather than abandon them (and all their friends and acquaintances) to the puppy mill trade; and deprive the shelter dog of the home.

Sadly, the vast majority of electronic fencing is used by people who install far less expensive, DIY fencing; do no training; have no professional inspection of the electrical work done; have no built in safeguards; and have no interest in the fencing beyond their own convenience. Much, much suffering is caused, as described in this article.

Also, one could argue that if the beep of the fence boundary is enough to make the dog not cross the invisible line, then even if they walk up toward a child and hear the beep, that could be enough to increase fear of children. It’s just so risky, as you know!

I have heard that the Invisible Fence staff are the “bad guys” during “training” and associate themselves with the shock, not the owner. But you’re right, if the owner forgets to take the collar off the dog can make a lasting bad association.